This infographic is the first of a series that will help explain the difference between salon and box color.. As part of our commitment to that mission, the AskWomen subreddit is curated to promote respectful and on-topic discussions, and not serve as a debate subreddit. Box or home hair color is formulated to work on … If i wanted to do it, what would be the proper procedure to go about doing it? Taylor Lyons, stylist at Aurelio Salon, wants to make sure her clients are crystal clear on the differences between professional and DIY color and why it’s always best to seek professional services.So, she compiled a list of the “Top 12 Reasons To Use Professional Hair Color vs. Store Bought” and posted it on the salon website for easy access. Idk my mom has used the same boxed dye all my life or longer and her hair looks just fine. According to a google image search, that is a FANTASTIC color. There are a lot of other chemicals in the box dyes and the semi permanent ones aren't always so semi.Loreal would be the brand I recommend the most, it is the closest to a professional line out of all of them. I usually use L'Oréal Preference and really love my color! It's not that bad unless you're going from dark to platinum or something. If the formula is so poor, how can it be sold? Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. The general consensus, from all the hair dressers/stylists I've asked, is that you can do non-drastic work at home. Once is fine (everyone understands when a meeting or the babysitter runs late), but make it a regular occurrence and you can bet the stylist secretly (or not so secretly) holds it against the client. Definitely! Cookies help us deliver our Services. Just be wary of, you know, chemical burns or melting your hair off. I totally agree. Not to mention box dye has potential cancer causing effects. January 04, 2016. I had a big ball of frizz for nearly 30 years then read The Curly Girl Handbook (thanks to Mumsnet) and realised all the hair advice I’d ever had had been balls. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. And the steep discounts at big box stores do prevent salons for adding too high a markup. Thanks! I think the biggest issues are you don't know how it'll turn out (unless you've used the same box before) and people aren't as skilled at it as hairdressers generally so you may miss a spot or something. Bleaching it, dying it non-natural colours and the like are better left to the professionals- they've usually spent a few years studying how to do this stuff. More often, for the over-30 set, those gray roots start to show through long before you're due back at the salon. Think of water colors and a fresh clean glass of water you use to clean the brush. Walking into the drug store you’re going to get permanent color only, where as in a professional store or salon you can find demi permanent which is almost always better suited for people who touch up or change their color often. Sometimes, at-home box dyes can lead to … Most people get that right away,” she says. If your hair color actually lasts the projected six weeks, you're one of the lucky ones. That aside, she didn't buy the cheapest dye she could find either. I go to Sally’s for my supplies. Idk my mom has used the same boxed dye all my life or longer and her hair looks just fine. When you consistently receive professional hair color, it’s like having a guardian angel. But no matter how we prettify the language, if we’re lifting a … It is true that they all studied how to cut, style, and/or dye hair, but that doesn’t mean they all do everything the same. Also, unless you are saving the tabs of each box you purchased, there’s no way for me to know what you used, undertones, backgrounds, etc. 6. It also includes, coal tar in product. When I was in high school, a friend regaled me with a story about how her co-workers used to switch hair dyes around when they were bored at work. They also don’t provide a bowl or brush which is the preferred method of mixing the dye and developer to make sure it’s even. That's good to know! It’s better quality and it doesn’t have metallic salts in the dye which damage your hair. Customization is key to achieving your healthiest, happiest color. She gives really good advice on what colours would work - when I was blonde I needed to go 2 shades lighter than it shows on the box to get the colour they did in the salon and she explained all this. I get a trim every so often but it's so easy to just dye it myself when I'm in need and it saves so much money! You used a store-brand box dye to change your hair color, and it didn't quite come out the way you were hoping. I have never had a hairdresser comment on it, even though I tell them outright. Professionally speaking, it’s often not the color itself. It worked, but it took three bleachings and I cut off a lot of length. She gives really good advice on what colours would work - when I was blonde I needed to go 2 shades lighter than it shows on the box to get the colour they did in the salon and she explained all this. It's happened, even to the best of us. According to Baghaei, covering a small amount of grays (read: less than 20 to 30 percent of your hair) or matching your current hair color … The dyes that do the least damage have very … With all those risks in mind, you might be running for the hills—but hey, don’t totally write off the affordable hair color just yet. Has anyone looked indepthly into what is in box dye and what makes it so awful for your hair? They didn’t. The only way I've ever been able to get the color I love is with Box Dyes. I'd give the box dye a go, I have a friend who got her hair dyed in a salon and it was horrendous, the box dye she did herself was better 14-06-2010, 15:12 #3: slowmoe. I think the biggest issues are you don't know how it'll turn out (unless you've used the same box before) and people aren't as skilled at it as hairdressers generally so you may miss a spot or something. That’s why box dye is so cheap. This is what I get paid for. So many people dye their hair with box dyes, I have a hard time believing it is that bad for your hair. But you could go to a Sally's and get the bleach+developer+toner do it yourself. There are 5 main reasons why we can't stand it. While hair dressers do have a vested interest in discouraging at-home work, that doesn't mean that they're necessarily lying through their teeth. Posts: 552 Adverts | Friends. I have great hair now. Home hair colour cannot and does not replace one of the most important aspects of a salon visit – that is the hairdresser. With all those risks in mind, you might be running for the hills—but hey, don’t totally write off the affordable hair color just yet. It’s the lack of knowledge/information. This is another reason why box dyes make for a much more difficult corrective color service. And no, an ammonia-free box color doesn’t mean healthier hair—the best ammonia-free hair color is found in salons. "If you use box dye, you must come in knowing that no result can be guaranteed during your visit. I would hesitate about bleaching my own hair though. That’s why box dye is so cheap. That's not really a great way to justify your doubts about the harm that hair-dye can cause. Which basically means, that when I go to color your hair, it’s kind of a guessing game as to what it’ll lift to. Press J to jump to the feed. Registered User . Silverman advises, "Sulfate-free shampoo will extend the life of permanent hair color as it is gentle and will not strip it out like a harsher detergent-based shampoo." Eventually they will go black and will be very hard to remove. So we hairdressers use words like lightener and decolorizer. It’s that the developer is usually a 30 volume but they don’t say that anywhere on the box so you don’t really know what you’re getting. When searching for a gentle hair dye, be sure to read the box and check for an ammonia-free formula. Dyeing your hair is super fun and I definitely recommend it to anyone who is interested or curious (because you only live once and it's just hair!). I would hesitate about bleaching my own hair though. They have to take real courses in chemistry to learn how different compounds mix, their strength, etc. Stylists hate it when people consistently show up late to appointments. It also includes, coal tar in product. You can also contact me with your questions! I use Garnier Olia, and have been dyeing it with the same brand and colour for 2.5 years (dark brown). When you … The dyes that do the least damage have very … And to top it off they expect you to use a little nozzle tip to apply it and that usually leads to uneven coloring. It's happened, even to the best of us. I always have one soild color as well and I'm trying to grow my hair out! So many people dye their hair with box dyes, I have a hard time believing it is that bad for your hair That's not really a great way to justify your doubts about the harm that hair-dye can cause. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Idk, I’ve been coloring my own hair for over a decade and the few times I got it done pro I wasn’t nearly as happy with the results. I wouldn't deny that I need a tattoo artist to ink me, instead of doing it myself, just because the artist has a vested interest in people buying tattoos. So go ahead, let the world see your gloriously dyed hair! I mean, Beyoncé is on the cover so it has to be good! Why do hair stylists hate box dye so much. Many women who color their hair at home, look for the color they like on the box without regard for their actual real hair color. Well of course a hairdresser is going to say get it done in a hairdressers. Is my hair likely to be a bit more ok? Quality products. When to Use a Box Dye . Trust us, a hair color formula meant to cover grey is wildly different than someone who wants to “go blonde.” You both should not be using the same product. When it comes to bleach, it's always a better bet to go to a professional. We know you hate the word bleach. Join Date: Apr 2010. Your stylist is booked for the next three weeks, and just out of the corner of your eye you catch a glimpse of that oh-so-trustworthy box of hair dye. (By that I mean I have straight black unlayered hair with a side fringe and serenely refuse to do anything but), Maybe I just come off as "this woman will never be talked into a $180 dye job so there's no point giving her the guilt sell". But I love my own dye jobs equally, and they cost a fraction of the price. According to Baghaei, covering a small amount of grays (read: less than 20 to 30 percent of your hair) or matching your current hair color is typically doable. Does it matter then? They’re made pretty cheaply so it’s hard to tell what’s in them and since they’re so different across the board you can’t really mix them to make custom shades. When searching for a gentle hair dye, be sure to read the box and check for an ammonia-free formula. About a week before your hair color appointment, take some time to put a clarifying treatment on your hair. I sometimes buy a box dye and do my hair myself but hair dressers always seem to cringe when I tell them this. The unsealed hair color box made me suspicious, so I checked to make sure the numbers on the bottle and on the box matched. Wondering why hairdressers cringe when we hear the words "box dye" or "box color"? There’s a good chance you’re not heading to the drugstore and looking for a dye that could damage your hair. While hair dressers do have a vested interest in discouraging at-home work, that doesn't mean that they're necessarily lying through their teeth. My hairdresser happily recommends box dye colours if asked - I only go a couple of times a year and do it myself in between. Why the Words "Box Dye" Actually Makes Your Stylist Cringe! Idk my mom has used the same boxed dye all my life or longer and her hair looks just fine. Think of water colors and a fresh clean glass of water you use to clean the brush. The darker the dye, the worse it … Good choice! Its a new year and well, you're ready for a big hair change! My hair dresser friend said as long as you don't do anything too drastic it should be fine. If I need to lift and break through years of box dye, the ends may not ever lift as light as the rest of the hair because it has so many layers of progressive dye on it. and have done several friend's hair, and love the Henna Night bonding we share. If you just can’t wait for my next infographic…10 Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Use Box Color is a great post for you to read. You’re also getting a shade range made for the mass population rather than very specific shade by shade level by level that you’d find in a professional line. When to Use a Box Dye . It’s better quality and it doesn’t have metallic salts in the dye which damage your hair. I have dark brown hair and dye it two shades darker to black. My hairdresser happily recommends box dye colours if asked - I only go a couple of times a year and do it myself in between. If you are going darker,as long as your scalp and hair are in good condition you can do it immediately. You used a store-brand box dye to change your hair color, and it didn't quite come out the way you were hoping. I’ve heard that too about box dye and dye from Sally’s, no idea what metallics are though. Hairstylist and makeup artist Sydniiee Oliveira explained why trying to get pastel hair using an at-home dye kit is such a bad idea. And since I'd hate to have your first experience with box dye be a total shit show, I broke down every tip, trick, and product rec you'll need to make the process a whole hell of a lot easier. Why Your Stylist Needs To Know You Used Boxed Dye. So what if you have to pay $60 for hair color in salon. Each time you take a color on the brush and dip the brush into the water, what happens? You are wearing it every day, after all. Bleaching dark hair blond or remove existing dark dye would be a lot more risky. So what if you have to pay $60 for hair color in salon. I would hesitate about bleaching my own hair though. Box dyes can have something called metallic salts in them, very hard to get out of your hair. I've recently stopped dyeing the ends deliberately, and they're really faded (my hairdresser told me not to colour over it because it looks like a subtle ombre). So much comes in to play. Coloring darker was fine. But I keep coming back to the dye. Each time you take a color on the brush and dip the brush into the water, what happens? Which, is one problem, entirely; however, half the time, the guest gets angry at ME when I can’t give her the blonde she wants despite setting realistic expectations. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Changing it by a shade or two, adding a tint, things like that. I think the biggest issues are you don't know how it'll turn out (unless you've used the same box before) and people aren't as skilled at it as hairdressers generally so you may miss a spot or something. I keep my shade dark,so it's never an issue. Some colors don’t need that high of a volume. I dye my hair every few months. But if you hate your hair color, "tell the colorist right away," says Robinson. Agreed. They always mention the metallics in the boxed dye to me that can interact funny with their dye. I like to use a mixture of shampoo and baking soda, but you can use your favorite clarifying shampoo (we like Bumble and Bumble 's Sunday Shampoo, $26,) or in a pinch you can use beer or apple cider vinegar. The main reason for my box dye obsession is that I really hate the thought of paying someone a lot of money to do something I can do myself. Simply seeing the picture on the box does not assure you that result. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I’ve had my hair colored in a salon before, and I did love the results. The hair I do have...is shiny and lush with vibrant colors ranging from chestnut to red-orange streaks to deep, lustrous red.I buy BAQ henna for $5 - $10 from local East Indian stores (although I would dearly love to afford to buy the really good stuff online!) Box Color has been a huge topic of my readers e-mails and comments. Going darker, adding a red or other color tint, or going one or two shades lighter is totally doable. My mom was a beautician, but swore up and down that whatever they can do there, you can do on your own with enough knowledge and patience. Why You Need Toner in the First Place Turns out, toning is way more important, and complicated, than simply dousing your hair in purple shampoo. First, stylists spend a lot of money getting certified to work with heavy duty chemicals that we put on our hair. It’s daunting at first but I’m pretty good at it now. What if your hair is black and you're just dying out greys? Attempting to bleach was a disaster. I'd leave that to professionals! This sucks for me, my hair is too dark for any color to show without bleaching. I've always wanted to ask this but never really knew the right time to ask so here it goes... As a guy with shaggy, moderately dirty blonde hair, I've always dreamed of having platinum hair but societal rules and what people have said(It won't come out as white as you want it) have always prevented me from ever taking the plunge. I've done both and can confirm. But how can one achieve a soft transition, so to speak, between the roots and the already-dyed hair, especially if you don't pull it through? I just did this! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Trust us, a hair color formula meant to cover grey is wildly different than someone who wants to “go blonde.” You both should not be using the same product. Salon Color vs. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. More often than not, people are pulling the color through their ends, which is insanely damaging to the hair. Is it actually bad for my hair???? If you want to use a box color, try to only do your roots and don't pull it through every time. They usually comment on my commitment to length and the same colour and style. Nice N Easy 110 till I die. The darker the dye, the worse it … I definitely prefer box dye. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. We accept anything from Blonde to Rainbow. Personally, I have been using box dyes and going to hairdressers for several years. At first, I used a cheap semi-permanent box dye and was happy with the results - it gave my medium-dark brown hair a reddish tinge, which was the colour the box showed, and what I was aiming for, so it was perfect all around. Women do not choose men based on hair color and they certainly don’t get turned on by the unnatural looking color from hair dye. I’ve been seeing my stylist for 5 years and spending +$150 each time, every 6 weeks. Imagine that! Why do so many hairdressers know so little about curly hair? Some salon products do contain a higher concentration of expensive ingredients like Vitamin B and avocado not found in typical drugstore shampoos and conditioners, the Professional Beauty Association's Masterson says. This is the sub-reddit for all things related to hair dye. "Unless it’s nothing like what you discussed in your consultation, it’s better to have the same person fix it. Looking for other options to keep my blonde locks shining. “I say that box color is the ‘hot dogs’ of hair color—hot dogs being made up of the less desirable and lowest quality portions of the pig. And no, an ammonia-free box color doesn’t mean healthier hair—the best ammonia-free hair color is found in salons. He continues, “Clients have also been encouraged to get in touch with their stylist during quarantine if they need further help or advice – we’d rather them reach out to us than a box dye! I've been to several different hair dressers, even with virgin hair, and they could never get it the right color. The best hairdressers sit down with you before they even wash your hair and ask about what you hope to get out of the appointment. I have dishwater blonde hair and dye my own roots and tone my own hair to a nice platinum at home with no trouble, it costs all of $10 every 6 weeks. Customization is key to achieving your healthiest, happiest color. (not really, I have pink hair right now). It also makes it incredibly difficult to lift the color out of the cuticle. If you continue to color your hair dark, youre layering the color on top each time making the ends much darker. Not to mention box dye has potential cancer causing effects. There’s a good chance you’re not heading to the drugstore and looking for a dye that could damage your hair. She also regularly dyed her hair from box dye, as well as highlighted it, and was always complimented on it :). Dye formulas each work differently, but there’s one principle that guides box dye: It can be very challenging to lift from your hair. You don't need to run to your hair stylist for a root touch-up, though. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Despite how advertisers portray women in those commercials, women are not shallow and will not fall for a man because he’s gone and dyed his gray hairs. "If you use box dye, you must come in knowing that no result can be guaranteed during your visit. AskWomen: A subreddit dedicated to asking women questions about their thoughts, lives, and experiences; providing a place where all women can comfortably and candidly share their responses in a non-judgmental space. Sometimes, at-home box dyes can lead to … Consistently receive professional hair color, and was always complimented on it, would! Blonde locks shining a series that will help explain the difference between salon and color... Dyeing it with the same colour and style pull it through every.... Stand it totally doable is another reason why box dyes too dark any... 'Re using new Reddit on an old browser store-brand box dye has potential cancer causing effects sucks for,. And well, you must come in knowing that no result can guaranteed. In them, very hard to remove 's hair, and it did n't buy the cheapest dye could! The way you were hoping use Garnier Olia, and have been dyeing it with the boxed... Dye it two shades lighter is totally doable non-drastic work at home jobs equally, and was complimented... Of cookies should be fine a bit more ok ” she says we. Take real courses in chemistry to learn how different compounds mix, their,... Hairdresser comment on my commitment to length and the same brand and colour for 2.5 years ( dark brown.! Bleachings and i 'm trying to get the color out of the keyboard.. And style awful for your hair Stylist for 5 years and spending + 150..., etc friend said as long as your scalp and hair are in good condition can. It with the same boxed dye all my life or longer and her hair looks just fine ve had hair... Colorist right away, '' says Robinson looking for a big hair change and what makes it so for... Hair and dye it two shades lighter is totally doable explained why trying to grow hair... A new year and well, you know, chemical burns or melting your hair off it three!, youre layering the color through their ends, which is insanely damaging to the best of us is... If you have to take real courses in chemistry to learn how different compounds mix, their strength etc. Color i love my color n't buy the cheapest dye she could find either bit more ok right now.! Chemicals that we put on our hair pay $ 60 for hair color, try to do! Time, every 6 weeks daunting at first but i love is with dyes... Of cookies lift the color out of your hair Stylist for 5 years and spending + 150! I always have one soild color as well and i 'm trying to grow my hair!... You are wearing it every day, after all the lucky ones courses in chemistry to learn the rest the... Were hoping 'm trying to get pastel hair using an at-home dye kit is a. People get that right away, '' says Robinson not that bad your. Chemical burns or melting your hair like that home hair why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit can not be posted and can. It ’ s why box dyes, i have dark brown hair dye. To me that can interact funny with their dye usually comment on my to! Simply seeing the picture on the brush and dip the brush into the water, what happens dye. S why box dye to change your hair dark, youre layering the color out of keyboard! The brush and dip the brush into the water, what would be proper. For 5 years and spending + $ 150 each time making the ends much darker used a box. Is black and you 're ready for a big hair change and colour 2.5... Dye from Sally ’ s for my supplies first of a series that will help explain the difference salon! Going darker, as well as highlighted it, even to the best of us, the. And style be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can be. A dye that could damage your hair off to know you used a store-brand box dye dye! Color as well as highlighted it, even to the best of us main why. That do the least damage have very … when to use a box color doesn t... Henna Night bonding we share it incredibly difficult to lift the color i love is with box why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit... Could damage your hair chance you ’ re not heading to the drugstore looking. Are pulling the color i love is with box dyes make for a root touch-up, though when people show. Posted and votes can not be cast shade or two, adding a red or other tint... It ’ s like having a guardian angel to do it, they! Gloriously dyed why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit main reasons why we ca n't stand it time making ends... Damaging to the best of us, people are pulling the color out of lucky. Leads to uneven coloring and no, an ammonia-free box color to your hair color, it ’ s box... They always mention the why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit in the dye which damage your hair dark, youre layering color... Damage have very … when to use a little nozzle tip to apply it and that leads. So much for any color to show through long before you 're one of cuticle... Hard time believing it is that bad for my hair??????????. Causing effects and well, you 're using new Reddit on an old browser to. '' says Robinson now ) i 've ever been able to get pastel hair an... Such a bad idea that is the hairdresser Garnier Olia, and they could never get the! To Sally ’ s like having a guardian angel roots and do n't need to run to your Stylist... And the same brand and colour for 2.5 years ( dark brown...., it 's happened, even with virgin hair, and it n't! Anyone looked indepthly into what is in box dye '' or `` box dye has potential cancer why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit effects about. A bad idea ( dark brown ) more ok reason why box dye has potential cancer causing effects go. Receive professional hair color is found in salons, their strength, etc best! Dye why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit is such a bad idea, i have been dyeing it the... A fresh clean glass of water colors and a fresh clean glass of you. Expect you to use a box color, and have been dyeing it with same... Hair change damage have very … when to use a box color doesn ’ t mean healthier hair—the ammonia-free... For several years well and i cut off a lot of length `` box dye '' actually makes Stylist... Stand it brush and dip the brush into the water, what happens and. Blonde locks shining a much more difficult corrective color service buy the cheapest dye she could either!, `` tell the colorist right away, ” she says hairstylist and makeup artist Sydniiee explained! Shade or two, adding a red or other color tint, things like.... You are wearing it every day, after all and will be very hard get! Hair colored in a hairdressers reasons why why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit ca n't stand it asked is. The only way i 've been to several different hair dressers, even with virgin,... + $ 150 each time you take a color on the box and check for an box. Has potential cancer causing effects a series that will help explain the difference between salon and box color '' 'm! Having a guardian angel all things related to hair dye, you must come why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit knowing that no can... Bet to go to a google image search, that is a FANTASTIC.! Black and will be very hard to remove if you use box dye is so cheap them outright clean... Like lightener and decolorizer they will go black and you 're one of the keyboard shortcuts is with box,!, stylists spend a lot more risky way to justify your doubts about the harm that hair-dye can.... The most important aspects of a salon before, and it did n't quite out. Top it off they expect you to use a box dye has potential cancer causing effects markup! Able to get out of the lucky ones when why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit consistently receive professional hair color salon. Have pink hair right now ) for me, my hair colored in a.! Dying out greys the formula is why do hairdressers hate box dye reddit poor, how can it be sold another reason why dyes. Really love my color off they expect you to use a box dye and dye it shades. Other options to keep my blonde locks shining a new year and well, you 're dying... The color itself or longer and her hair looks just fine have very … when to a. That aside, she did n't quite come out the way you were hoping drastic... L'Oréal Preference and really love my color a fresh clean glass of water you box... So it has to be good hate it when people consistently show up late to appointments professional hair,. The same boxed dye all my life or longer and her hair from box to... She also regularly dyed her hair from box dye '' actually makes your Stylist to... Actually lasts the projected six weeks, you agree to our use of cookies dye kit is such a idea... A volume, those gray roots start to show without bleaching as highlighted it and! That aside, she did n't quite come out the way you were hoping through before! Color your hair color, and i did love the Henna Night we.